On Coscinomancy

Thanks to a query of A. Venkatesh, I have just been looking at the tangled and instructive etymology of the word sieve…

To the Greeks, a sieve is a koskinon (κóσκινον), whether it be of use as a cooking utensil, or as devised by that clever fellow, Eratosthenes, to find prime numbers. But the English word has a completely different etymology, of Germanic origin if the OED is to be believed.

From the same source, I’ve learnt that a coarse-meshed sieve can also properly be called a ridder or a riddle (the latter being an alteration of the former). In this form, it is said to be related to the Indo-European stem kreit-, which is also, as it turns out, (carrying a meaning of to separate, to judge) at the root of many fine words, such as crisis, critic, criterion; through the Latin cribrum, it leads to the French word for sieve, namely crible. (Though, as far as cooking is concerned, the instrument is rather called a tamis in French cuisine; this last word, although considered obsolete, does exist in English, as does the variant temse…)

As for the Greek word, it has left no trace in French, and (apparently) remains in English only under the guise of a delightful word, coscinomancy, which I regret not having known about at the time of deciding on the title of my inaugural lecture:

coscinomancy, n.
Pronunciation: /ˈkɒsɪnəʊˌmænsɪ/

Etymology:
< medieval Latin coscinomantia, < Greek κοσκινόμαντις, < κόσκινον sieve.

Divination by the turning of a sieve (held on a pair of shears, etc.).

1603 C. HEYDON Def. Iudiciall Astrol. xvii. 356 Comparing Astrologie with Aruspicie, Hydromancie, Chiromancie, Choschinomancie, and such like.
1653 H. MORE Antidote Atheism (1712) III. ii. 89 Coskinomancy, or finding who stole or spoiled this or that thing by the Sieve and Shears.
1777 J. BRAND Observ. Pop. Antiq. (1870) III. 301–2.
1871 E. B. TYLOR Primitive Culture I. 116 The so-called coscinomancy, or, as it is described in Hudibras, ‘th' oracle of sieve and shears’.

(To quote the OED again; note the amusing oscillations of the popularity of this word…)

Published by

Kowalski

I am a professor of mathematics at ETH Zürich since 2008.

3 thoughts on “On Coscinomancy”

  1. “Sieve” is also used in category theory (see Grothendieck topology in Wikipedia). One way of drawing a sieve would be to make a picture of a bunch of arrows all pointing at one object (with different domains). In about 1966, the Belgian mathematician Paul Dedecker visited Case Western Reserve University and gave talks on category theory. He called sieves “cribles”, apologizing that he didn’t know the English word. He tried to explain by referring to St Stephen and to soldiers in World War I riddled by machine gun bullets. His audience was totally baffled. Many years later my wife became an Episcopal Deacon and I learned that St Stephen was supposedly the first deacon and was martyred by many soldiers shooting arrows at him. Suddenly, All Was Clear.

  2. It’s interesting; I hadn’t connected the French “criblé de flèches” with the English translation “riddled with arrows”, but now the link is clear!

  3. I actually used “riddle” in one of my first papers to present a sieve optimised for situations where few elements are sieved out at each step (e.g. a square-free sieve).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *